Billing & Claims

Billing and Payments

Did you know that our companies offer you a variety of quick, convenient ways to pay your premium? Save time, save stamps, save the hassle!

Here are all the payment options that are available to you:

Grange Insurance Pay Online
Pay by Phone: 800-425-1100

Pay by Phone
To pay by phone using our Automated Payment System, please call 888-974-7400.

Pay Online

Pay by Mail

Selective Insurance Company of America
Box 371468
Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468
*include your bill account number on your check.
Progressive Insurance Pay online
Pay by phone: 800-925-2886 or 800-876-5581
 Safeco Insurance Account Services
 Travelers Insurance Pay online
Log into "Your Account" on the right side of Travelers home page
 Westfield Group Insurance Payment options
Medical Mutual Insurance 

Pay by phone: 800-384-0991 (Individual Policyholders only).
Please have the invoice number available when you call.  Checks and credit cards accepted.  Individual policyholders can now pay on-line through My Health Plan.

 Anthem Insurance Pay by phone:
Individual Policyholders - 800-362-8322
Group Policyholders - 888-290-9159

 

Report a Claim

If you need to report a claim, we're here to help. Just call us at 419-884-1836 or toll free at 866-415-1255.

If you need to report a claim after hours or on the weekend, you can report your claim directly to the insurance company:

Aetna Insurance Claim forms
 Grange Insurance 24 Hour Claims Reporting - 800-445-3030
Auto glass claims - 800-951-9734
Progressive Insurance 24 Hour Glaims Reporting: 800-925-2886
Auto glass claims: 800-925-2886
Submit a claim online  
Report a Claim
 Safeco Insurance 24 Hour Claims Reporting: 800-332-3226
 Travelers Insurance 24 Hour Claims Reporting: 800-CLAIM33 (800-252-4633)
Submit a claim online
 Westfield Group Insurance 24 Hour May-Day Line: 800-443-3311
Westfield Glass Service: 800-810-3665

 Water, Fire or Mold Claims? ProClean Ohio has 24 hour service!