About Us

Our staff is friendly, hard-working, eager to serve your insurance needs and one of the most knowledgeable and experienced groups of people in the insurance business.

We are members of the MarketSource Agency Network, the National Association of Professional Insurance Agents and National Health Underwriters Association.

Our Staff......

Mark Reitler, President                                                              

Mark graduated with a Bachelor of Science degree from Ohio State University.  Mark started in the insurance industry as a claims adjuster with Auto-Owners and Grange Insurance Companies.  Since joining the agency in 2000, Mark has focused on managing the personal and business lines.  As the owner of Reitler Insurance, Mark focuses on client development and risk management for Commercial Lines.  Mark earned his Certified Insurance Counselor (C.I.C.) designation in 2011. 

Robert Reitler, Agent                                                                              

Bob has been a full-time professional insurance agent for over 35 years. Originally from the Oak Harbor, Ohio area, Bob and his wife Beth moved to Lexington in 1982 to purchase and operate the Streib Insurance Agency which was originally founded in the late 1950’s.  Bob offers a wealth of experience & knowledge in the areas of Farm Insurance, Business Insurance, Life Insurance & Annuities as well as a special focus and knowledge of Long Term Care Insurance. 

Beth Reitler, Health Agent                                                                         

Beth graduated with a Bachelor of Arts degree from Ohio University and began her career as a paralegal at a Columbus based insurance defense litigation law firm.  Beth joined the agency in 2007 with the focus on Health Insurance Products.  Beth has earned P&C and Health/Life Licenses with the Department of Insurance as well as an advanced designation as a Chartered Benefit Consultant focusing on the Consumer Drive Health Products such as H.S.A. and H.R.A. plans.

Rebecca Matney, Account Manager

Rebecca graduated with her Business Administration B.S. from Ohio University and has a background in both programming and insurance.  She worked for Ohio Mutual, Shelby Insurance and North Central State College.  Rebecca joined Reitler Insurance Agency in 2010, earned her Property & Casualty License with the Department of Insurance and manages the Personal & Commercial Lines accounts.

Becky Wolleson, Account Manager                                                                             

Becky graduated with a B.S. degree from the Ohio State University in 2005. Becky started her career during college as an assistant office manager for a small collections business, and has since worked for Manpower and The Mansfield Art Center gaining over seven years of human resources and office management expertise. Becky earned her Property & Casualty License with the Department of Insurance and manages Personal Lines and Health Accounts.